Sundays with Duke #32: The Mellow Tone

We’re still parked in 1940 with Duke Ellington, and we’ve hit another classic: In a Mellotone.

Let’s spin the original Victor recording:

Johnny Hodges and Cootie Williams are in peak form — Cootie even slips in a sly quote from Never No Lament at the tail end of his solo — but it’s Jimmie Blanton’s bass that steals the spotlight. His lines practically glow.

From Mellotone to Mellow Tone

Duke kept the tune in the band’s book throughout the 1940s, but the song found a second life in the 1950s when producer Milt Gabler added lyrics and nudged the title toward the now-familiar In a Mellow Tone.

Milt had The Mills Brothers record it for Decca in 1955 with Sy Oliver arranging:

It’s a delight — how can you beat the Mills/Oliver combination?

Funny that it took fifteen years for someone to add lyrics — the melody practically chants “in a mellow tone” on its own.

Ella Steps In

Once lyrics existed, Ella Fitzgerald naturally grabbed the tune for her 1957 Duke Ellington Songbook album — one of my favorite playgrounds:

Ella stretches out beautifully here, weaving between the written lyrics and her trademark scat. And yes, Ben Webster is still along for the ride, adding that warm velvet to the edges.

Duke Revisits the Instrumental

Duke circled back to the tune in 1960 for his Columbia album Blues in Orbit, keeping it strictly instrumental:

By this point, the “Mellow Tone” title had fully overtaken the original “Mellotone” spelling — the mellow won.

Louis Joins the Party

Duke recorded another instrumental version in 1961 with Louis Armstrong on Recording Together for the First Time — another favorite playground:

It’s interesting that Louis doesn’t sing the lyrics — even though they existed by then — yet he scats on Cotton Tail, which didn’t have lyrics. Satchmo gonna Satchmo.

And just to keep us on our toes, the label lists the tune as In a Mellowtone!

Here's a link to Duke and Louis performing the song in 1961 on The Ed Sullivan Show:

It's great that so many Sullivan shows were preserved so we can enjoy seeing these wonderful artists!

Betty's Baby

As far as I can tell, Duke never recorded a version using Milt Gabler’s lyrics. But things get wonderfully twisty when we get to Betty Roché, whose specialty with the Ellington band featured a totally different set of lyrics.

Here’s a 1953 live recording of Betty singing the Baby, You and Me variant:

The announcer mentions the lyrics and title change at the beginning and says it's "soon to be released" at the end — but I can't figure out what release he's referring to!

As far as I can tell, Duke never cut a studio version of that variation, but Betty did — for Bethlehem in 1956:

And here’s the fun part: Bethlehem kept the title In a Mellow Tone and even credited Milt Gabler, despite the lyrics being completely different. I’m guessing Milt didn’t write both sets… but you know we love a little label intrigue!

Billy Brings the Moves

We close out with a wonderfully wacky take on the tune, as Billy May turns it into a cha‑cha for his 1960 Capitol album Cha Cha!:

Billy was well‑known for his sense of humor, and it absolutely shows here — the arrangement is playful, brassy, and just a little mischievous. And what a good sport he was to pose for the album cover in that get‑up. The man committed to the bit!

Whatever the Title…

Whether it’s Mellotone, Mellow Tone, Mellowtone or even Baby, You and Me, one thing stays constant — the tone is mellow!