Sundays with Duke #10: Flippin' and Ringin'

We’re flipping over Duke Ellington’s record of Three Little Words to find a Duke original that also made its debut in the 1930 film Check and Double Check: Ring Dem Bells.

The Original: Duke Ellington (1930)

This Victor recording is famous for its high energy and the literal bells ringing out, but the real highlight is the scat vocal by trumpeter Cootie Williams. It shows a playful side of the band that worked perfectly for the silver screen.

The Reunion: Lionel Hampton (1939)

While the song didn't get many covers immediately, it picked up serious steam by the end of the decade. In 1939, Lionel Hampton recorded this burner for Victor. Hamp was with Benny Goodman at the time and was leading stellar "pick-up" groups for recording dates.

If you check the label, you'll see a powerhouse combo of Goodman and Ellington sidemen—and Cootie Williams is right there revisiting the tune! Keep an ear out for Hamp giving a shout-out to pianist Jess Stacy.

The Arrangement: Charlie Barnet (1940)

Charlie Barnet "helps" Billy May with an arrangement!

As I’ve mentioned before, Charlie Barnet was a massive Ellington and he had the good fortune to employ a young Billy May as arranger. For this 1940 Bluebird session, they turned Ring Dem Bells into a modern swing masterpiece.

Let's spin it:

The Clouds of Joy: Andy Kirk (1941)

Andy Kirk admires the arrangement by Mary Lou Williams!

Another legendary architect of the era was pianist and arranger Mary Lou Williams - The Lady Who Swings the Band! Here she is providing a sharp, driving arrangement for Andy Kirk and his Clouds of Joy on Decca. It’s a testament to the song’s durability that it sounded just as fresh in 1941 as it did in 1930.

If you listen closely to the brass figures behind the solos, you can hear the same sophisticated DNA that Mary Lou would later bring to her arrangements for Duke himself. She was one of the few who could speak Duke’s musical language fluently and still add her own Kansas City grit to it.

The Solo Stamp: Fats Waller (1941)

Finally, we see the song move from the big bands to the solo piano. The incomparable Fats Waller put his own unmistakable stamp on the tune for the Victor album Hot Piano. Without the bells or the brass, Fats proves that the "swing" was built into the melody all along.

With so many legends taking a swing at this one, which version rings your bell? Are you a fan of Cootie’s original scatting or Fats’ solo piano stride?